29 First Valentine’s Day Gifts That Prove You Pay Attention (Without Overdoing It)

Maison Margiela's Replica perfumes channel the big and little moments together, so every time they're spritzed, it's like you're instantly transported back to that special memory. Surprise your lover with a fragrance that feels personal to your connection. Love your daily walks together? Spring Time in a Park smells like an afternoon in the sun. Maybe the two of you first met over lattes—Coffee Break will bring you back. There are so many options to choose from that let you nod to your fave memories together.

Now here's a gift that lets you capture your moments together in real time. A Polaroid camera is playful and nostalgic—truly a perfect gift for couples early in their relationships. Add some batteries and a scrapbook and get to snappin'.

If they have 9,000 photos on their phone they can't seem to ever remember to print out, they'll adore this mini printer. The Canon Ivy connects to smartphones via Bluetooth, so all they have to do is choose their favorite pics and click "print"—that's it. It prints sticky-back images they can slap on mirrors, laptops, journals, and more, so they can finally get the pics out of their phone while saving a trip to the printer.

Is it silly? Yes. Is it adorable? Also yes. This is a peak first-Valentine’s-Day move: sweet, funny, and low-pressure. Ideal if your shared love language is memes, inside jokes, or breakfast together.

Upgrade their shower routine with Cyklar's incredibly scented body wash. The vanilla scent is warm, cozy, and universally appealing—aka very safe but still special. It turns an everyday shower into a ritual, and it's so nourishing on the skin too, they'll feel like they just stepped out of a high-end spa. (Or go for the Body Cream version, which actually won Best Scented Body Cream in our Holy Grail Beauty Awards for 2025!)

Okay, some heart-shaped jewelry is acceptable, like this silver bracelet from Jenny Bird. It's not the cheesy heart-shaped baubles you were warned against—it's bold, modern, and fun, not dainty or overly precious. The chunky charm and chain links feel "It girl" with a '90s touch.

If his pajama collection consists of a college T-shirt and ratty boxers, get him these. Eberjey makes the comfiest PJs he'll probably ever own. They're breathable, drapey, and elevated enough to feel gift-worthy, made from a featherlight tencel modal that feels softer with every wash. Perfect for stealing for yourself at your next sleepover.

If you want to splurge a bit without going overboard, consider gifting your lover a watch. This vintage-inspired one from Heaven Mayhem feels fashion-forward without being flashy, which makes it a great first-Valentine’s-Day gift. The leather band looks good with everything, while the small gold frame looks instantly classic.

Skims is internet-famous for a reason. This lounge set is absurdly comfortable and basically guarantees they’ll think of you every time they wear it—which will be often. Good luck not buying a pair for yourself.

It's Valentine's Day after all—why not get sexy!? This soybean candle melts into warm, erotic massage oil, setting the vibe without crossing into “too much, too soon” territory. Light it up and see what else sparks. It’s subtle, sultry, and veeeery on-theme for the holiday.

A chaotic couples game that will test communication, patience, and teamwork—all in a fun way, ofc. It's ideal if you’ve already bonded over cooking, gaming, or playful competitiveness. For a first Valentine's Day gift, it's a cute way to get to spend some more quality time together when you run out of things to watch on Netflix.

A bouquet they can build ticks off both boxes of gift-worthy florals and something to connect over. This Lego set is charming, unexpected, and gives you something to do together. Plus, they don't die!

For the partner who takes their R&R super seriously, a quality bathrobe makes a great present. This striped beauty from Brooklinen fits the bill—the plush fabric feels like a warm hug no matter where they wear it, whether it's over coffee at breakfast or just out of the shower. Plus the stripes feel trendier than just another classic white.

If you both are counting down the days until your next romantic getaway, get her something she can use on your trip. This leather makeup case will let her stash all the favorite toiletries she can't possibly leave behind on vacay. It looks pretty, too—gorgeous enough to leave out on the bathroom counter.

MeUndies are wildly comfortable and come in the cutest patterns for the holiday, and beyond. These boxer briefs are made out of the brand's signature micromodal fabric that literally feels like butter against skin, so he'll never take them off. Bonus points if you get a matching pair (which you can) and rock 'em together.

For the person who is always cold. This blanket is plush, cozy, and heats up to a whopping 122 degrees Fahrenheit, so they'll never have to be chilly again. And it's so soft, designed in a dreamy faux fur. Good luck getting them out from under this thing.

Gift them Quince's SuperSoft Fleece Crew and instantly level up their cozy game. This sweatshirt feels like that perfect worn-in hoodie you never want to take off—only way chicer. It comes in five versatile neutrals, like white, navy, and gray, that look great with the matching bottoms. Get them a set for a gift they'll be endlessly thankful for.

For your first Valentine’s Day, this Cuban curb chain is a Goldilocks kind of piece worth gifting: stylish and trendy but not too luxe or extravagant. It’s classic enough for him to wear every day, even with jeans and a T-shirt, yet elevated enough to feel like a thoughtful gift. It comes in two finishes (gold and silver), three lengths, and two widths (3mm and 5mm)—basically, everything you need to find his perfect match.